TU Berlin

Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Möhring Algorithm Engineering for Real-time Scheduling and Routing

Page Content

to Navigation

Algorithm Engineering for Real-time Scheduling and Routing


Project Overview

Problem Description

While 20 years ago microprocessors have mostly been used in desktop computer workstations and large-scale computers, they have meanwhile become ubiquitous. They are used in nearly all areas of technology and specifically in safety and mission critical applications. The future vision of the automotive and avionics industry is complete, safe and reliable drive-by-wire and fly-by-wire respectively. Such industrial applications gave rise to the field of computer science which is called real-time scheduling and routing. Whereas classical scheduling deals with the distribution of a finite set of tasks to a set of machines, real-time scheduling deals with recurring tasks which are often periodic and thus appear infinitely often. Since the processors in a real-time system communicate by passing messages, the messages have to be routed through the architecture (modelled as a directed graph) additionally.

The goal of the project is to develop, implement, analyse and test algorithms for real-time scheduling and routing problems using methods of linear and integer programming as well as various scheduling and routing techniques from discrete optimization.

Real-time scheduling under hard periodicity constraints


Hard periodic real-time scheduling problems are motivated by special requirements of real-time systems arising in safety critical environments, e. g. the avionics or automotive industry. Here, system designers need to schedule highly critical periodic control tasks with a predictable and static scheduling policy such that preemption and dynamic effects are avoided. For that reason, a hard periodic execution schedule is required. Here each task ti=(c(ti),p(ti)) releases a job of running time c(ti) periodically exactly every p(ti) timeunits. The problem is to find stating offsets that ensure that no collision of different jobs occurs.

Our research led to a characterization of the complexity landscape of the problem both in terms of approximation algorithms and inapproximability results (see Eisenbrand et al., ICALP 2010). Based on insights gained in the theoretical analysis, we also designed an algorithm and a solver that can tackle, for the first time, large previously unsolved instances from the avionics industry (see Eisenbrand et al., ESA 2010).

Although we made significant progress both in understanding the theoretical nature of the problem and solving it in practice, still there are important questions left open that we address in further research.

Deadline constrained real-time scheduling


In deadline constrained real-time scheduling we have more relaxed feasibility requirements as in the case of hard periodic scheduling. Instead of requiring perfect periodic execution of the tasks, the jobs released periodically by the tasks have to be executed within a certain given time span after their release, specified by its relative deadline di. In the important special case of implicit deadlines the relative deadlines match the task periods, i. e. we have pi = di for all tasks, this means that a job of a task should be finished before the next one is released.

We studied two scheduling policies. For static-priority systems, the rate-monotonic scheduling policy is considered. Here, whenever two unfinished jobs are available at the same time, the one with the lower period is prioritized. For dynamic priority systems, the earliest-deadline-first policy is studied. Here, whenever two unfinished jobs are available at the same time, the one with the closer deadline is prioritized. The reason to consider these policies is that they are provably optimal, i.e., whenever an instance is feasible under any static/dynamic priority policy, it is also feasible under rate-monotonic/earliest-deadline-first policy (see Liu and Layland, 1973). We contributed significantly to a better theoretical understanding of these problems by providing, amongst other things, an average case analyis (Karrenbauer and Rothvoß, ESA 2009; Davis et al., Real Time Systems 2009), approximation algorithms (Karrenbauer and Rothvoß, WAOA 2010) and hardness results (Eisenbrand and Rothvoß, APPROX 2009; Eisenbrand and Rothvoß, SODA 2010).

Scheduling jobs with shared memory

Embedded real-time systems are often implemented upon heterogeneous hard-
ware, consisting of several distinct processors, each with its own instruction set.
This trend towards platform heterogeneity is becoming more pronounced as real-time systems increasingly come to be implemented upon multicore platforms. Specialized hardware components are used that accelerate certain computations—examples include multicore CPUs with specialized graphics processing cores, signal-processing cores, floating-point units, customizable FPGAs etc. The heterogeneous multiprocessor platforms upon which embedded real-time systems are implemented often possess a shared pool of memory in addition to the computing cores (see Hady et al., 2009).

Therefore, we want to investigate real-time scheduling problems under the additional constraint that the jobs need to share a common pool of memory. The jobs which are active at any time must not exceed the total available memory of the system.

As a first step to understand the shared memory constraint, we investigated classical static offline scheduling problems where we additionally impose this constraint. We developed approximation algorithms for several variants of the offline scheduling problem (see Niemeier et al., ECRTS 2011;  Niemeier and Wiese, WAOA 2012). While the offline variant is, to some extent, well understood, fundamental questions in the online and real-time scheduling variant are still open. Our next step is to contribute to a better understanding of these variants of the shared memory scheduling problem. 

Routing real-time messages

The problem to send a given set of messages through a communication network on time is a very involved problem of high practical relevance, even the special case in which all messages have unit size (i.e., the packet routing problem). We distinguish between the packet routing and the more general message routing problem, consider these problems on simple network topologies, with and without restrictions on the number of sources and sinks, release times, deadlines, travel times and capacities. Moreover, since packet routing is strongly related to dynamic flows, we aim to develop and translate techniques and ideas from the theory of dynamic flows to design efficient algorithms for the packet and message routing problem on the one hand, and on the other hand, contribute with our results to a better understanding of dynamic flows.

Scheduling and routing dependent periodic tasks

While in the above we investigate real-time scheduling of periodic task systems and real-time routing of messages separately, the goal here is to develop algorithmic methods which can deal with the combination of the two problems: imagine a periodic task system with dependencies among the tasks in the sense that the successful execution of the jobs of one task might require the information of the jobs of another task. Thus, in case two dependent tasks are assigned to different processors, the corresponding information needs to be routed through the communication network linking the processors. This ambitious goal involves critical routing and scheduling decisions which affect each other. Before we approach this goal, we investigate the problem to schedule periodic task systems with dependencies but without any routing decisions. Also, we study the problem to route periodic messages through a network given that the tasks are already scheduled. 


Liu, C. L. and Layland, James W.
Scheduling algorithms for multiprogramming in a hard-real-time environment.
J. Assoc. Comput. Mach., 20:46–61, 1973.

Hady, F. T. and Cabot, M. B. and Beck, J. and Rosenbluth, M.
Heterogeneous processors sharing a common cache.
United States Patent 7,577,792. Assignee: Intel Corporation, 2009.


Eisenbrand, Friedrich and Hähnle, Nicolai and Niemeier, Martin and Skutella, Martin and Verschae, José and Wiese, Andreas
Scheduling periodic tasks in a hard real-time environment.
In Abramsky, Samson and Gavoille, Cyril and Kirchner, Claude and Meyer auf der Heide, Friedhelm and Spirakis, Paul G. (ed.)Automata, Languages and Programming (ICALP 2010), pp. 299–311, Springer, 2010.  [pdf]

Eisenbrand, Friedrich and Kesavan, Karthikeyan and Mattikalli, Raju S. and Niemeier, Martin and Nordsieck, Arnold W. and Skutella, Martin and Verschae, José and Wiese, Andreas
Solving an Avionics Real-Time Scheduling Problem by Advanced IP-Methods.
In de Berg, Mark and Meyer, Ulrich (ed.)Algorithms – ESA '10, pp. 11–22, Springer, 2010.  [pdf]

Koch, Ronald and Peis, Britta and Skutella, Martin and Wiese, Andreas
Real-Time Message Routing and Scheduling.
In Jansen, Klaus and Naor, Joseph and Rolim, Jose (ed.)Approximation, Randomization, and Combinatorial Optimization. Algorithms and Techniques, 12th International Workshop, APPROX-RANDOM 2009, Berkeley, USA, Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Springer, Vol. 5687, pp. 217–230, 2009.

Niemeier, Martin and Wiese, Andreas and Baruah, Sanjoy
Partitioned Real-Time Scheduling on Heterogeneous Shared-Memory Multiprocessors.
In Proceedings of the 23rd Euromicro Conference on Real-Time Systems (ECRTS 2011), 2011.
to appear.  [pdf]

Peis, Britta and Skutella, Martin and Wiese, Andreas
Packet Routing: Complexity and Algorithms.
In Bampis, Evripidis and Jansen, Klaus (ed.)Approximation and Online Algorithms, 7th International Workshop, WAOA 2009, Copenhagen, Denmark, September 2009. Revised Papers, pp. 217–228, Springer, 2010.  [pdf]

Skutella, Martin and Peis, Britta and Wiese, Andreas
Packet Routing on the Grid.
In Lopez-Ortiz, Alejandro (ed.)Theoretical Informatics, 9th Latin American Symposium, LATIn 2010, Oaxaca, Mexico, Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Springer, Vol. 6034, pp. 120-130, 2010.

Peis, Britta and Stiller, Sebastian and Wiese, Andreas
Policies for Periodic Packet Routing.
In Cheong, Otfried and Chwa Kyung-Yong and Park, Kunsoo (ed.)Algorithms and Computation - 21st International Symposium, ISAAC 2010, Jeju Island, Korea, Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Springer, Vol. 6507, pp. 266–278, 2010.

Peis, Britta and Wiese, Andreas
Universal packet routing with arbitrary bandwidths and transit times.
In Integer Programming and Combinatorial Optimization (IPCO 2011), pp. 362-375, Springer, 2011.

Peis, Britta and Wiese, Andreas
Throughput Maximization for Periodic Packet Routing on Trees and Grids.
In Approximation and Online Algorithms (WAOA 2010), pp. 213–224, Springer, 2011.

Davis, Robert and Rothvoß, Thomas and Baruah, Sanjoy and Burns, Alan
Exact quantification of the sub-optimality of uniprocessor fixed-priority preemptive scheduling.
Kluwer Academic Publishers, Vol. 43, pp. 211–258, 2009.

Eisenbrand, Friedrich and Rothvoß, Thomas
EDF-schedulability of synchronous periodic task systems is coNP-hard.
In Proceedings of the ACM-SIAM Symposium on Discrete Algorithms (SODA 2010), pp. 1029–1034, 2010.  [pdf]

Eisenbrand, Friedrich and Rothvoß, Thomas
New Hardness Results for Diophantine Approximation.
In Proceedings of the 12th Intl. Workshop on Approximation Algorithms for Combinatorial Optimization Problems (APPROX 2009), Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Vol. 5687, pp. 98–110, Springer, 2009.  [pdf]

Karrenbauer, Andreas and Rothvoß, Thomas
An Average-Case Analysis for Rate-Monotonic Multiprocessor Real-time Scheduling.
In Proceedings of the 17th Annual European Symposium on Algorithms (ESA 2009), Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Vol. 5757, pp. 432–443, Springer, 2009.  [pdf]

Karrenbauer, Andreas and Rothvoß, Thomas
A 3/2-Approximation Algorithm for Rate-Monotonic Multiprocessor Scheduling of Implicit-Deadline Tasks.
In Proceedings of the 8th International Workshop on Approximation and Online Algorithms (WAOA 2010), Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Vol. 6534, pp. 166-177, Springer, 2011.

Eisenbrand, Friedrich and Rothvoß, Thomas
Static-priority Real-time Scheduling: Response Time Computation is NP-hard.
In IEEE Real-Time Systems Symposium (RTSS), 2008.  [pdf]

Niemeier, Martin and Wiese, Andreas
Scheduling with an Orthogonal Resource Constraint.
In 10th Workshop on Approximation and Online Algorithms (WAOA2012), 2012.


Quick Access

Schnellnavigation zur Seite über Nummerneingabe